What Your Renters Insurance Doesn’t Cover—And How to Fill the Gaps
Renters insurance is one of those smart “adulting” moves. It protects your belongings from major events like fire, theft, or water damage—things no one wants to deal with, but everyone should be prepared for.
But here’s the thing: renters insurance doesn’t cover everything.
There are plenty of everyday situations that can still leave you footing the bill—and for renters trying to stay on top of expenses, those costs can sting. Whether it’s a surprise pet mishap, damage you’re liable for, or smaller fees that fall through the cracks, the gaps in your coverage might not show up until it’s too late.
Here’s what renters insurance often leaves out—and what you can do to stay protected.
1. Pet Mishaps
Your pet might be the sweetest part of your home, but even well-behaved animals can leave behind messes that cost you. Whether it’s scratched floors, stained carpets, or chewed-up blinds, these kinds of damages can quickly eat into your security deposit—and renters insurance usually won’t cover it.
However, with CSC Marketplace, you’ve got options to soften the blow. You can book a professional cleaner through Thumbtack and get $100 off your first job—making it easier to erase the mess before your landlord sees it. And if you do get hit with a charge, services like Home Assist can reimburse you for surprise damage fees. You can even find affordable pet insurance from Lemonade to help cover future accidents, so unexpected costs don’t derail your budget again.
2. Surprise Landlord Fees
You thought you were in the clear—until a surprise charge shows up after move-out. Maybe it’s $200 for paint touch-ups, or a cleaning fee you didn’t see coming. These unexpected fees can eat into your deposit fast, and renters insurance won’t help cover them.
However, with CSC Marketplace, you’re not stuck footing the whole bill. CSC Marketplace helps you plan ahead—and protect your wallet if things don’t go as planned. Sign up for Home Assist by Latchel to get up to $2,700 in reimbursements for landlord fees, lockouts, and more. Your first month is free.
These small steps make it easier to stay protected—and keep more of your money when it’s time to go.
3. Small Repairs or Wear-and-Tear
That loose cabinet handle? The dented wall from your couch move? These kinds of small but visible issues can end up costing you. While they may not feel major, property managers often charge for basic wear-and-tear repairs if they see an opportunity.
Renters insurance typically won’t help here either. It’s meant for bigger disasters—not scuffed floors or minor fixes that feel “normal” to you but not to your landlord.
4. Lockouts and Emergencies
We’ve all had those moments—your keys are inside, and you’re outside. Or worse, you’ve lost them completely. Some landlords will help (for a fee), but others leave it up to you to call a locksmith.
These day-to-day emergencies often fall outside traditional coverage, and they can quickly become expensive and stressful.
Final Thoughts
Renters insurance is a smart safety net—but it isn’t the whole picture. By knowing what it covers (and what it doesn’t), you can protect yourself from the small things that cause big headaches later.
If you’re looking for smarter ways to stay covered, CSC Marketplace is here to help. We’ve vetted the solutions, negotiated the deals, and made them easy to access—all in one place.
Because when it comes to where you live, the fewer surprises, the better.
Shop deals
Lemonade Car Insurance
Car insurance people actually love. Only available in AZ, IL, OH, OR, TN, TX, WA.
Assurant Renters Insurance
No credit check, no hassle. Just renters insurance made easy.
Lemonade Pet Insurance
Save up to 90% on diagnostics, procedures, and medication.
CSC Home Assist w/ Latchel
Save an avg of $600/yr for damages, key replacements, and fees from your landlord.
